Coinfully Review: Is it the Best Way to Sell Gold Coins Online?
I recently sold a large gold coin collection to Coinfully, a company that purchases gold coins, silver coins, and other rare coins with a streamlined online process.
Selling coins can be stressful. For months, I wrestled with the decision of whether or not to sell my gold coin collection. I tried a few local coin dealers and was sorely disappointed with their quotes every time.
While trying to estimate the value of my gold coins myself, I happened to stumble upon Coinfully, an online coin service that buys gold, silver, and rare coins.
I was initially impressed with their website and promises of top offers and a simple selling experience. After researching the company, I decided to get a free appraisal (it couldn’t hurt, right?) and see where it led. This detailed review covers everything I learned along the way.
What Is Coinfully?
Coinfully is a Charlotte, North Carolina-based online company that appraises and buys gold coins, silver coins, rare coins, and coin collections through a streamlined online process, though in-person, at-home services are offered as well for large or historically important collections.
This company was founded by brothers Travis and Wyatt McDonald with a mission to make the coin-selling process transparent, efficient, accessible, and highly rewarding without ever having to leave your home and deal with traditional coin shops.
Coinfully offers free, expert appraisals and competitive offers for a wide range of U.S. coins and provides a secure, no-pressure environment backed by outstanding customer service and an A+ BBB rating.
Across the board, Coinfully has positive reviews across their online platforms, including 167 reviews on Trustpilot with a 4.8 star rating, an A+ BBB rating with a 4.7 star rating, and 4.6 rating on Google.
For a smaller company in the online coin buying space, this broadly reflects customer satisfaction with their online coin selling process.
The company is an authorized dealer with major numismatic organizations, including the American Numismatic Association (ANA), Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS), Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC), and Certified Acceptance Corporation (CAC).
Types of Coins Coinfully Buys
Coinfully purchases gold coins, silver coins, entire coin collections, gold and silver bullion, and rare numismatic treasures via online appraisals or in-person evaluations.
Whether you want to sell individual gold and silver coins, an inherited coin collection, or rare coins you’ve spent a lifetime collecting, Coinfully’s team of professional numismatists is fully equipped to assess your coins and offer a fair, top-market price.
They specialize in U.S. coins, graded and ungraded items, and full collections of any size or complexity.
Their flexibility and expertise make them especially approachable for people who may not know the full value of what they have.
Gold Coins
Coinfully buys a wide variety of gold coins, including American Gold Eagles, Canadian Gold Maple Leafs, South African Krugerrands, and pre-1933 U.S. gold coins, such as the $20 Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle, $10 Indian Head Eagle, and $5 Liberty Head Half Eagle.
They also evaluate rare international gold coins, commemoratives, and certified (graded) gold coins from PCGS and NGC. Each piece is appraised for both gold content and collector value.
Silver Coins
I found Coinfully’s approach to silver coins just as comprehensive. In addition to bullion coins, such as American Silver Eagles, Canadian Silver Maple Leafs, and Austrian Silver Philharmonics, they also buy 90% U.S. “junk silver” coins, such as pre-1965 dimes, quarters, and half dollars, as well as Morgan and Peace silver dollars.
Graded and collectible silver coins, such as early U.S. commemoratives, Carson City Morgans, and rare foreign silver issues, are also welcomed and appraised with care.
When they appraised my Peace and Morgan dollars, they didn’t just make a bulk offer—they considered the mintmarks, condition, and grading potential for each one.
That level of detail gave me confidence that they weren’t lowballing or treating everything as scrap silver, which can happen with other buyers.
Rare, Historic, and Graded Coins
Coinfully specializes in evaluating rare and historically significant coins, particularly those that are professionally graded by PCGS, NGC, or CAC. Examples include key-date coins such as the 1909-S VDB Lincoln cent, the 1916-D Mercury dime, and the 1893-S Morgan dollar.
They also consider Colonial-era coins, early U.S. Mint issues, and commemoratives with strong market demand. Whether the rarity is due to mintage numbers, condition, or historical context, Coinfully offers expert assessments and competitive offers.
Entire Coin Collections
Coinfully is uniquely equipped to handle entire coin collections, from modest assortments to large, curated numismatic holdings. Their team takes the time to evaluate each piece individually while also recognizing the collection’s overall value.
They frequently work with estates, retirees, and collectors ready to sell, providing itemized appraisals and the option for at-home concierge service.
Whether the collection spans decades or includes a mix of U.S., bullion, and graded coins, Coinfully ensures every coin is properly valued.
How Selling Coins on Coinfully Works
Coinfully allows you to easily sell gold coins online, as well as silver and other rare coins, and has designed the coin-selling process to be remarkably clear, efficient, and user friendly.
- Create Photos or an Inventory Listing: Photograph your coins or create a detailed inventory list. Coinfully provides guidance on how to take effective photos to ensure accurate appraisals.
- Receive Appraisal and Accept Offer: After reviewing the submitted information, Coinfully provides a detailed appraisal and top-of-market offer. The appraisal documentation is also accepted by insurance companies and for legal purposes.
- Ship Coins and Get Paid: If you accept the offer, you ship your coins directly to Coinfully via Priority Mail. Packages are fully insured by Lloyd’s of London and opened under 4K security cameras. Upon verification, payment is issued promptly that very day.
I found the process refreshingly straightforward—there was no complicated jargon and no pressure, and I appreciated how communicative they were at every step.
Whether you’re selling a single coin or a full collection, Coinfully’s approach makes what could be a complicated transaction feel simple and secure.
Where Coinfully Truly Shines
While many coin buyers offer appraisals and purchasing services, Coinfully sets itself apart through its customer-focused approach, expert knowledge, and transparent processes.
Every aspect of the experience—from the initial appraisal to final payment—reflects a commitment to professionalism and integrity. Their team doesn’t just make offers; they educate, explain, and guide sellers through a process that’s often unfamiliar or overwhelming.
Free, No-Pressure Appraisals
Coinfully offers complimentary, no-obligation appraisals for all types of coins and collections. You can begin the process by submitting clear photos through their website or setting up a call for a more in-depth consultation.
There’s no pressure to sell—in fact, their team emphasizes educating the seller and giving them time to decide. It’s a low-stress, respectful experience that focuses on helping clients make informed decisions, not fast sales.
Concierge Service
For particularly valuable, rare, or historically significant qualifying collections, Coinfully provides a white-glove concierge service. In these cases, a professional from their team will travel directly to your home or specified location to perform an in-person evaluation.
This service is ideal for estate collections or high-value portfolios that require special handling and care. This provides a level of personal attention that other buyers simply don’t offer.
Complete Transparency
Coinfully’s dedication to transparency is one of its most impressive qualities and was a major selling point for me.
They don’t just provide a lump-sum offer—they break down the value of each coin and explain how that value is determined based on condition, rarity, and current market demand.
They even share what they expect to resell the collection for and explain their professional margins. This level of documentation and insight is rare in the industry and helps sellers feel informed and empowered.
Buys U.S. Coins, Silver and Gold Bullion
Unlike many local coin shops that focus primarily on U.S. coins, Coinfully evaluates and buys both domestic and international coins and paper currency.
Their team has experience with everything from U.S. silver dollars to world gold coins, European numismatics, and old banknotes.
This makes them a great option for those with inherited collections that contain a wide variety of pieces, especially for those unsure of what might be valuable.
Top-of-Market Offers
Coinfully consistently delivers top-of-market offers, thanks to a combination of expert numismatic knowledge and business efficiency. Their team understands the intricacies of coin grading, market demand, and global pricing trends.
Plus, they operate without the overhead of a physical retail location, allowing them to pass savings onto sellers. Their access to a wide network of collectors and dealers around the world means they can offer competitive prices that reflect real-time market value, not just local demand.
Fully Insured Shipping
When you accept an offer, you can ship your coins with confidence, as each package is fully insured by Lloyd’s of London for the full estimated value of the collection. This ensures your coins are protected every step of the way, from your home to Coinfully’s secure facility.
They even provide detailed packing instructions to help prevent damage in transit, and Coinfully pays for shipping on any offer higher than $1,000.
Fast Payment Guaranteed
Once your coins arrive at Coinfully’s headquarters and are verified, payment issued on the same business day. You can choose to receive your funds via check or secure bank wire, depending on your preference.
The speed and reliability of their payment process make them stand out in a field where delays and vague timelines are not uncommon. It’s clear they prioritize the seller’s experience from beginning to end.
The Only Downsides to Coinfully
While the list of benefits provided by Coinfully is long, I only found three minor drawbacks.
First, if you live in the Charlotte area and want to stop in for a quick appraisal, you’re out of luck. Coinfully operates a fully online service and has no physical location.
Also, they don’t offer appraisals for error coins. This certainly isn’t a deal-breaker, but it may be applicable to some potential customers.
Lastly, Coinfully does not sell coins —they only buy. Those looking to add to their collection will have to go elsewhere.
My Personal Experience
I admit that selling coins online can be a little scary, especially when it comes to dropping off your coin collection at a shipping facility.
However, Coinfully made every step of the process easy, from the initial contact and inventorying my collection to shipping and receiving payment.
To begin the appraisal process, I carefully followed their clear instructions for photographing and inventorying my coins and sent the information. I was shocked when I heard back within hours!
The offer I was given was a lot more than what local dealers offered, and Matt patiently took the time to answer all my questions.
Knowing that my coins were fully insured made packaging my collection and sending it off much easier. Within hours of my coins’ arrival at their destination, payment landed in my bank account.
No stress, no lowball offers, and no pressure—it doesn’t get any easier than that!
What Other Users Shared
My positive experience seems to be the norm when dealing with Coinfully, especially considering their 4.8 rating on Trustpilot and a 4.6 Google rating. Take a look at some of these stellar reviews:
“The whole team at Coinfully was easy to work with from initial email looking for some information, to the following email conversation with Braden. All of my questions were answered thoughtfully and promptly. From that point, once everything was agreed, the rest of the process couldn’t have been easier. Thank you again to the whole group at Coinfully.” ~ Chris R.
“I couldn’t have asked for a better experience! Matt was friendly, knowledgeable and helpful. I will definitely use Coinfully in the future if I decide to sell anymore coins. The process was incredibly smooth. I had some trepidation about the idea of someone coming into my home but that quickly passed after speaking with Matt on the phone. As a first time coin seller, I can’t recommend Coinfully enough.” ~ Deidre R.
“This has to be the easiest process I’ve ever experienced with selling any coins. Not only did I receive top dollar, but the money was wired into my account the same day they received my coins. I would recommend this company to anyone looking to sell and be treated very professionally.” ~ Doug W.
The Final Word
Whether you’re a seasoned collector or someone who inherited coins and isn’t sure where to begin, Coinfully stands out as a trusted, knowledgeable, and refreshingly transparent buyer.
Their expert team, personalized service, and commitment to educating sellers make the entire process seamless and stress free. From fair appraisals to fast payment and exceptional customer care, Coinfully delivers on every promise.
If you’re considering selling gold coins, silver coins, or rare coins, I strongly recommend reaching out for a free appraisal—you might be surprised by what your collection is truly worth.
